top of page

In Between the Negatives: Aaryaman Kutty on Colour Grading from a Preservation Lens

21 hours ago
12 min read

Updated: 2 hours ago

"In Between the Negatives" is part of a larger research collaboration across India, Taiwan and Brazil called the Arkebara Collective that is working toward a preservation manifesto. It is rooted in Majority-World filmmaking realities rather than borrowing from institutions that were never built for us. Among these are women whose processes have gone undocumented twice over: once on set, and once in the historical record. This series is itself an attempt at preservation.


Aaryaman Kutty is a Mumbai-based colourist and filmmaker. He graduated from Prague Film School in 2019, worked in Prague for two years, then returned to India and joined Bridge Postworks. Aaryaman learned grading on a digital medium, and later worked on a few films shot on film. As of 2026, he operates as a freelancer. His films have screened at Sundance, Tribeca, Berlinale, IFF Rotterdam and Busan IFF, among other festivals. The short film Anuja (2025), which he graded, was nominated for an Oscar in the live action short category. He has graded two NYU film school productions shot on 16mm: Incroci (2023, Berlinale) and If I Make It to the Morning (2024, BFI Flare). 


A digital monitor captures a guy managing a color grading station in the dark.
Aaryaman Kutty at the colour grading desk for Bobby Beauty Parlour (2024) (via Janhavi Asthana).

Context – Why a Colourist in This Research?

Aaryaman is the only interview subject in this research who works exclusively in post-production. His inclusion addresses a gap in the broader research about film preservation: while the other interviews approach preservation from the production side, which sets the agenda for what gets decided on set, Aaryaman represents the first person downstream who must work with those undocumented choices. He simply receives the footage, along with whatever information the director and DP choose to share, and from that he must make consequential judgments about colour, contrast, density and mood.


I noted while introducing the research to him that the colourist is one of the only job roles that exists in both filmmaking and film restoration, making his perspective uniquely valuable as a bridge between the two worlds. 


Film vs Digital – The Colourist's Perspective


Before we proceed, it is perhaps best to distinguish coloring processes. Aaryaman offers a precise and useful articulation of the difference between grading film and digital from a colourist's standpoint:

"With film, you already have a look baked into it. There's a certain aesthetic, a certain contrast – the way highlights roll off – that's already pre-built into the look of the film stock you choose. Whereas with digital, there's more freedom to play, but it feels less organic."

He describes film as a "more defined canvas" and digital as a "flatter canvas". As a colourist, he prefers film precisely because so much of the work has already been done during principal photography. His role is thus to accentuate and enhance rather than construct from scratch. He notes that many digital colourists spend considerable effort mimicking what film stocks do naturally – the way it treats hues, skin tones, contrast, depth in colors and highlight rolloff – and that this mimicry is almost always less successful than the original.


He also articulates his philosophy of grading more broadly: the colourist's work should never be the complete transformation of an image. The ideal is that 80 to 90 percent of the look is achieved on set, and the grade provides the final refinement. This is why film, which imposes its aesthetic at the point of capture, is philosophically aligned with his approach in a way that digital often isn't.


Grading Films Shot on 16mm


A woman lays in bed listening to music.
Still from Incroci (2023) dir. Francesca de Fusco.

Aaryaman has graded two films shot on 16mm: Incroci (2023), directed by Francesca de Fusco, was shot on 250D by Sofia Camargo. His point of communication on this project was primarily the director rather than the DP, which he notes is sometimes a function of working relationships formed during production. The approach to the grade was largely subtractive, keeping things consistent and close to what was shot. 


If I Make It to the Morning (2024), directed by Andre Shen, was shot on 16mm by Gaby Clingman. This project involved significantly more work in the grade, particularly around contrast and skin tones. The director gave him considerable creative autonomy, asking him to do a pass, show options, and make decisions, partly because the scanned footage felt like it was "missing a little bit of a body to the image, like a bit of definition in the real depth." He worked through multiple options with both the director and DP, which necessitated more dialogue than he’d had on Incroci.


A close-up of a woman with long hair in warm light.
Promotional image for If I Make It to the Morning (2024) dir. Andre Shen.

He notes another meaningful difference between the two experiences: for Incroci, the grade was about consistency and restraint; for If I Make It to the Morning, it was about actively building the image to achieve what the shoot hadn't fully captured. Both are legitimate approaches, but they represent disparate responsibilities for how the colourist must engage with the DP’s footage.


What He Receives and What He Doesn't


For both 16mm projects, Aaryaman did not receive written documentation. He knew the stock for Incroci – 250D – but was not given information about whether it had been pushed or pulled during development, its processing conditions, or any quality control reports from the lab.

"Mostly you get the mood board and the pitch deck – why certain colours are there for certain characters, and then it's a conversation about emotion and what you're trying to feel."

For digital projects, the situation is much more transparent, as he usually knows of the camera and lenses. But even here, critical information sometimes comes late or not at all. He recounts receiving Bobby Beauty Parlour (2024) (which was notably shot by me, the researcher who conducted this interview), and not knowing until 20 minutes before the first grading session that everything had deliberately been shot one to one-and-a-half stops overexposed with the intention of preserving shadows and bringing highlights down in post. The footage looked wrong to him until he received that information.


"If you've intentionally underexposed or overexposed it, letting the colourist know helps a lot. Because what happens is I put the LUT (look up table) on it, I see the exposure, and if there's a big difference, I'm going to assume you shot it like that for an intentional reason. I might not touch it when I should."

That this happened between two collaborators who know each other personally, not strangers working across institutions or decades, underscores that the documentation gap is structural. 


He also identifies grain management as a recurring challenge with 16mm. When making strong adjustments to a 16mm scan, the grain comes with it. Pulling up highlights means pulling up grain texture, which can become distracting. Denoising and reapplying grain is the work-around, but it involves judgment calls about how much grain was intentional and how much was a consequence of conditions on the day. Without documentation of the shooting conditions, those calls are guesses.


The Ethics of Interpretation


One of the most substantive exchanges in the interview concerns the ethics of making decisions without sufficient information. Aaryaman has never worked on a project where the director or DP failed to collaborate; the director at least is always present. But he recognises that film preservation represents exactly that scenario: a colourist working on a restoration with sometimes no living collaborators to consult.


It is often the case in restoration that no crew members can be found to consult. Film conservator and archivist Jamie Chih-Yun Yao told me that in this case, existing prints serve as important reference copies, as a projection print was likely the closest approximation to what audiences saw (the historical viewing experience). However, if no print is available, then working with only negatives would indeed be a creative process of pulling RGBs based on human interpretation, sometimes accompanied by other references like photos.

"It's pretty crazy, if you are preserving and you have to go back in and dial certain parts like contrast, without any DP, without any director – on what basis do you take those calls? Because there is a certain idea of intent for each frame, and you doing your own thing doesn't justify it, especially ethically. When you're preserving, you want to keep it as close to what is possible. Even if it looks incorrect to you as a technical artist, it is what it was. It's a reflection of that time and how that film was shot. You can't change that."

Even if something was a technical limitation of the film or the technology of its time rather than a deliberate choice, it is still not the preservationist's call to correct it.


Having a DP or director supervise the restoration may become tricky for the process. While they can certainly give clues about certain looks and colors, many filmmakers would take the opportunity to exercise their authorial intent – to modify the work, to achieve what wasn't possible due to technical constraints or improve what they thought they had done wrong in the past. Some, including Chih-Yun Yao, might then say it is actually better for the restoration process if the director or DP is no longer around.


This position, that preservation requires restraint even in the face of apparent technical imperfection, is one that he arrives at intuitively, without having studied preservation formally. In fact, that aligns precisely with the ethical frameworks of film preservation.


Restoration Without Documentation


Aaryaman recounts being told about the restoration process for a commercial Indian feature from the early 2000s. They had the original 35mm scans, which were projected by a 35mm projector onto a movie theater screen in Andheri East (Mumbai). The colourist and the director’s assistant (DA) would begin the session by watching the 35mm projection and making notes. Then they would head to the colour studio, project the digital copy (MP4) and adjust the scans. The cycle was concluded with a return to the theater in order to cross-check for accuracy.


The digital intermediate artist working on the restoration was using a laptop copy (MP4 file) of the original film and matching the projected remastered scans, scene by scene, with what they could see on the laptop screen.


Aaryaman observes that a laptop is not a calibrated reference monitor, and two laptops will render the same file differently. The colour rendition of an MP4 – its metadata, its compression, its rendering – cannot be assumed to represent the original correctly. This is particularly true for older films where the original colour timing was photochemically adjusted with printer lights.

"That's the thing – on what basis do you keep that as your Bible? Because of the density, there can be myriad differences while you're rendering a file.”

He contrasts this and proposes this approach instead: working from the film scan itself on a calibrated reference monitor, grabbing stills from each scene, and making adjustments only within the parameters of what colour timing of that era could have achieved – red, green, blue, cyan, magenta, yellow and exposure. Nothing more.

"Earlier when they used to shoot on film, it was mostly like colour timing, basic printer light adjustments and exposure. That's all they used to really do. Everything else was kind of in the stock when they shot it, pre-planned. Now you have the control to change a lot of things. So some filmmakers like to go ahead and do it. Some don't."

Archival Documentary Work 


Aaryaman spent time working on documentary projects at Bridge Postworks that required extensive use of archival footage, including Bay of Blood (2023), The Hunt for Veerappan (2023), Indian Predator: Beast of Bangalore (2022) and The Greatest Rivalry: India vs Pakistan (2025). This work gave him direct experience of the Indian archival landscape from a colourist's perspective.


He observes: the worst-preserved footage was often the most recent. News channel footage from the 2000s, shot on digital or Digital Video (DV) cameras, stored on tapes and later transferred, arrived in worse condition than properly scanned film stock from the 1970s and ‘80s. In some cases, the offline placeholder (a low-quality proxy used for editing) was better than the final archival file delivered by the news channel.


By contrast, restored film scans delivered in the Kodak digital system Cineon log from the same period were immediately workable and of demonstrably higher quality. He specifically recalls cricket footage of a young Sunil Gavaskar that arrived as a properly scanned file being of visibly superior quality to digital news material from the same era.


A graph depicting Cineon with other film scanner system qualities.
Cineon color display quality in comparison with other contemporary systems (via Cineon).

Videotapes are generally more perishable than film and deteriorate at a faster rate. They have shorter expected lifespans and lower quality of images than photochemical film. Film heritage scholar Giovanna Fossati described them as "poor preservation carriers". Therefore, it's not surprising that the condition of a DV tape is worse than that of scanned film. That said, we can also reasonably argue this to be the result of a broader economic trend: the well-preserved archival footage was treated this way because it had commercial value: it was regularly licensed for use in documentaries and therefore maintained. In this way, preservation is often a byproduct of ongoing commercial demand rather than because of its innate historical value.


Aaryaman also raises the question of institutional archiving for news: he suspects much of the 2000s news footage arrived from tapes that were simply ripped and sent, bypassing any proper digitisation workflow. It’s ironic that physically older film stock was more accessible and of higher quality than digitally-shot material from 20 years ago.


He recalls being in the studio while a colleague, Mahak Gupta, was grading Indira's Emergency (2023), a film composed entirely of archival footage. The contrast with Bay of Blood was instructive: the archival material for Indira's Emergency was of consistently high-quality restored stock. He attributes this partly to the historical and political significance of the subject matter, which likely motivated better institutional preservation of the source material.


The Resurgence of Film in India 

Aaryaman is measured about whether there is currently a resurgence of film in India. He acknowledges that the infrastructure is more accessible than it was – more labs, more awareness, but still describes the phenomenon as extremely niche. He does not believe that a mainstream Bollywood film will shoot entirely on film in the near future, and questions whether the industry's relationship to digital has changed too fundamentally for that to happen.

"The way that we approach filmmaking as a process has changed. People want to see immediately after shooting. Directors don't have that same trust in their DP. Obviously, the developing thing is there, but it's not the way it used to be."

He notes that even at Bridge Postworks, a known colour and picture-finishing studio where Aaryaman worked for over three years, he encountered only two or three films shot on actual celluloid. He knows of a few more in circulation but considers it a very small world. He does, however, see the advertising industry as a space where film is making more of a return, citing a recent Adfilm. But that does not mean that there is exclusively hope for film in advertising; in fact, he predicts that more features may revert to the medium soon. 


He also raises a logistical point about equipment: the revival of film in India is constrained not just by labs and stock, but by available camera bodies. The equipment currently in use, which includes the Arriflex 416 used on Tiger's Pond, is often sourced from studios that were selling off old stock, or found through informal channels, et cetera. There is no active ecosystem for it.



The Director vs DP Conversation – Emotion vs Technique


Aaryaman brings attention to the communication differences and importance of it – both with the director and the DP, which feels useful to know for restoration too. He draws a clear distinction:


With directors, the conversation is about emotion. A director will tell him they want a scene to feel "secluded" or "warm as an emotion, not warm as a colour temperature." These are the conversations he finds most useful, partly because he is also a filmmaker and thinks in those terms, and partly because emotional direction allows him to make genuine creative contributions rather than just executing technical corrections.


With DPs, the conversation is more technical – protecting specific exposure decisions, maintaining lighting ratios and preserving colour temperatures. He respects this and finds it equally necessary, but notes that directors sometimes arrive with high-contrast visual references and then, when they see that same contrast applied to their own footage, want to dial it back. The subjectivity of what people think they want versus what they respond to when they see it is a recurring dynamic in the grading suite.


He also identifies a meaningful gap: directors generally cannot (and should not) be expected to speak in technical terms about the image. If they could, the colourist's role would be different. The translation between emotional intent and technical execution is where much of his work actually is, and where undocumented decisions from the shoot can make that translation harder.


Notes for Future Preservationists


When asked what note he would leave for a future preservationist working on his own graded projects, Aaryaman answers with reference to Anooya Swamy’s Pankaja (2026):

"There was a certain intent in colour – that film is supposed to feel colourful – garish, vibrant, in juxtaposition with what's actually happening in the film’s world. The image should not be muted, the vibrancy of the colour should still be there."
A note from James Cameron to projectionists of 'Avatar: Fire and Ash'.
A note left to theater technicians projecting Avatar: Fire and Ash (2025) (via Aaryaman Kutty).

Aaryaman recounts reading that some filmmakers do this for projectionists and he references James Cameron's practice of sending notes directly to projectionists specifying luminance levels and projection standards for the Avatar franchise – a model of intent-documentation that he finds compelling. The projectionist, he notes, is the last person through whom the film passes before the audience sees it, and they are therefore responsible for whether the filmmaker's intent is realised. The same is true of a restoration colourist, should a film be restored some years down the line.


On the broader question of how much preservationists should hold to the original image versus making it accessible to contemporary audiences, Aaryaman is genuinely uncertain:

"Once it's out there, it's out of your hand[s]. Even if someone is seeing it incorrectly, if it does the job of creating that same mood, is that fine? Maybe. You can't be completely rigid about restoring it exactly to the way the director or the DP wanted. Maybe sometimes getting it out there is more important."

The “fidelity” cause remains up for dispute,  and could very well prompt  even more profound research. The tension between authorial intent and modern film aesthetics  is one of the central unresolved questions in film preservation philosophy.


For the final piece in the series, and per the natural course, this research has taken me toward the politics of preserving female filmmaker’s works. I interviewed Fowzia Fathima, co-founder of Indian Women Cinematographers’ Collective (IWCC). She talks about the importance of visibility, self-preservation and what informal collectives like IWCC can do for the cause in the absence of institutional backing.


-Janhavi


Editor's note: Janhavi pointed out that maintaining British spelling is an important part of preserving her unique voice and language. BFB has resolved to henceforth honor the spelling practices of each writer based on the region that they were educated in.

Comments


Subscribe to our newsletter

©2026 by Buffed Film Buffs LLC 

  • Instagram
  • X
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn

Disclaimer: the views and opinions expressed on the blog are the writers' and do not necessarily reflect those of Buffed Film Buffs LLC.

bottom of page